The Worst Superhero Movies

Capes, costumes, catastrophes: the superhero and comic-book movies in the WorstWatchers catalog with the highest WorstWatchers score (0–100, higher = worse) – from Marvel and DC to the forgotten '90s misfires.

As of 2026-11-18 · 39 titles · Score 0–100, higher = worse

  1. 1Steel – CoverSteel1997 · Movie · Action, AdventureShaquille O'Neal in armour with a hammer – a DC hero without an audience.76
  2. 2Captain America – CoverCaptain America1990 · Movie · Action, AdventureCaptain America on a shoestring – Albert Pyun's forgotten Marvel adaptation.76
  3. 3Catwoman – CoverCatwoman2004 · Movie · Action, CrimeHalle Berry in leather scraps — the whip only hits the script.75
  4. 4Superman IV: The Quest for Peace – CoverSuperman IV: The Quest for Peace1987 · Movie · Action, AdventureSuperman sets out to abolish nuclear weapons – and meets Nuclear Man.75
  5. 5Max Steel – CoverMax Steel2016 · Movie · Action, Sci-FiMax Steel without steel — the action hero folds already at the trailer.74
  6. 6Zoom – CoverZoom2006 · Movie · Action, ComedyTim Allen trains super-kids — anything is faster than this film, sleep included.73
  7. 7Batman & Robin – CoverBatman & Robin1997 · Movie · Action, Sci-FiMr. Freeze, Poison Ivy and a director's apology – Batman's low point.73
  8. 8Turbo: A Power Rangers Movie – CoverTurbo: A Power Rangers Movie1997 · Movie · Action, FamilyA space pirate, a volcano demon, new Turbo powers – "No no, Power Rangers."71
  9. 9Fantastic Four – CoverFantastic Four2015 · Movie · Action, Sci-FiTrank's Fantastic Four without joy — dull, downbeat, woefully misguided.70
  10. 10Madame Web – CoverMadame Web2024 · Movie · Action, Sci-FiDakota Johnson sees the future — predictable and uneven, says the consensus.69
  11. 11The Adventures of Sharkboy and Lavagirl 3-D – CoverThe Adventures of Sharkboy and Lavagirl 3-D2005 · Movie · Action, AdventureA child's dream in 3D — the glasses make the headache pop.68
  12. 12Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance – CoverGhost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance2011 · Movie · Action, FantasyA burning skull and still not a single idea that catches fire.67
  13. 13The Spirit – CoverThe Spirit2008 · Movie · Action, CrimeFrank Miller paints Will Eisner's hero in black, white, and blood red — and forgets only the heart, the plot, and the fun.67
  14. 14Elektra – CoverElektra2005 · Movie · ActionA ninja assassin without a mission that sparks.67
  15. 15Kraven the Hunter – CoverKraven the Hunter2024 · Movie · ActionAaron Taylor-Johnson hunts — a paper tiger, per the consensus.66
  16. 16Thunder Force – CoverThunder Force2021 · Movie · Action, ComedyMelissa McCarthy and Octavia Spencer as superheroes — Netflix power outage.66
  17. 17Barb Wire – CoverBarb Wire1996 · Movie · Action, Sci-FiPamela Anderson as a bounty hunter in a comic-book Casablanca remake.66
  18. 18The Fantastic Four – CoverThe Fantastic Four1994 · Movie · Action, Sci-FiThe Marvel film that was never allowed into cinemas – shot to keep the rights.66
  19. 19Hellboy – CoverHellboy2019 · Movie · Action, FantasyDavid Harbour under the horned wig — reboot without del Toro magic.65
  20. 20Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles III – CoverTeenage Mutant Ninja Turtles III1993 · Movie · Action, FamilyTime travel to feudal Japan – the Turtles in sequel slump.63
  21. 21The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen – CoverThe League of Extraordinary Gentlemen2003 · Movie · Action, FantasySean Connery's last film role: Victorian heroes versus the "Fantom".62
  22. 22Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles – CoverTeenage Mutant Ninja Turtles2014 · Movie · Action, ComedyMichael Bay produces Turtles — Megan Fox saves pizza, not the film.60
  23. 23The Old Guard 2 – CoverThe Old Guard 22025 · Movie · Action, FantasyImmortal heroes, mortally dull exposition — and Uma Thurman as a subscription bonus.59
  24. 24Superman III – CoverSuperman III1983 · Movie · Action, Sci-FiSuperman versus a supercomputer – and endless slapstick.59
  25. 25Green Lantern – CoverGreen Lantern2011 · Movie · Action, Sci-FiA superhero ring with limitless power — and zero imagination.58
  26. 26Dark Phoenix – CoverDark Phoenix2019 · Movie · Action, Sci-FiX-Men finale without sparks — Jean Grey burns; the franchise glows.57
  27. 27Morbius – CoverMorbius2022 · Movie · Action, HorrorJared Leto as Living Vampire — memes beat the film.56
  28. 28Suicide Squad – CoverSuicide Squad2016 · Movie · Action, AdventureAyer cut on trailer tempo — B+ audiences, critics in chaos.56
  29. 29Captain America: Brave New World – CoverCaptain America: Brave New World2025 · Movie · Action, Sci-FiSam Wilson as Cap — mutant president, tired critics, mixed world.55
  30. 30Joker: Folie à Deux – CoverJoker: Folie à Deux2024 · Movie · Drama, MusicalPhoenix and Gaga sing — CinemaScore D for the musical experiment.55
  31. 31Aquaman and the Lost Kingdom – CoverAquaman and the Lost Kingdom2023 · Movie · Action, FantasyJason Momoa dives — sequel without a breakwater moment.55
  32. 32Supergirl – CoverSupergirl2026 · Movie · Action, Science FictionSupergirl 2026 — DCU launch-candidate; scores still trench-warfare zone.54
  33. 33Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice – CoverBatman v Superman: Dawn of Justice2016 · Movie · Action, FantasyZack Snyder has gods slug it out — B with audiences; critics in trench war.52
  34. 34Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Out of the Shadows – CoverTeenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Out of the Shadows2016 · Movie · Action, ComedyBay Turtles part two — a bit more spark, still lots of CGI.52
  35. 35Black Adam – CoverBlack Adam2022 · Movie · Action, FantasyThe Rock as antihero — B+ audiences; critics stay underpowered.50
  36. 36Justice League – CoverJustice League2017 · Movie · Action, FantasyTwo cuts, one franchise trauma — theatrical remains the WW case.50
  37. 37X-Men Origins: Wolverine – CoverX-Men Origins: Wolverine2009 · Movie · Action, Sci-FiWolverine has adamantium bones — the screenplay, sadly, does not.50
  38. 38The Shadow – CoverThe Shadow1994 · Movie · Action, FantasyAlec Baldwin as an invisible avenger in 1930s New York – stylish but bloodless.50
  39. 39Power Rangers – CoverPower Rangers2017 · Movie · Action, Sci-FiMorphin' with an A from audiences — critics only half as thrilled.49

More lists