Watson
WorstWatchers score: 49/100 – higher = worse
Sherlock dead, clinic live, procedural on autopilot.
A year after Sherlock Holmes fell, Dr. John Watson (Morris Chestnut) runs a rare-disease clinic in Pittsburgh — and hunts Moriarty on the side through DNA databases and patient-of-the-week cases. CBS mixes Elementary DNA with House MD feel. Critics call the concept shaky; Chestnut carries what the script will not. Two seasons, then canceled. You stay for the diagnostic puzzles — and because Sherlock as a hallucination eventually shows up again.
Pros
- Morris Chestnut holds the clinic together even when the script wobbles.
- Patient-of-the-week with a Holmes twist: at least the diagnostics stay playable.
- Two seasons until cancel — enough material for a gravestone night.
Cons
- Rotten Tomatoes 53 percent. Consensus: Holmes lore and medical procedural fit poorly.
- Metacritic 54. Chicago Tribune: charisma yes, scripts no.
- IMDb 5.6. Audience 34 percent Popcornmeter — viewers were done faster than CBS.