Treasure Island

2026 Series Adventure, Drama, History

WorstWatchers score: 65/100 – higher = worse

Stevenson walks the plank — in a tricorn.

A sailor washes ashore with Captain Flint's treasure map, and soon Jim Hawkins (Tom Sweet) and his mother Bess (Hayley Atwell) sail the Hispaniola toward gold. Aboard: Long John Silver (David Oyelowo), mutiny already up his sleeve, and British spy Aaron Graham (Jack Huston) with his own agenda. MGM+ stretches Stevenson's classic across six episodes — with a detour into the San Domingue revolution and Mom as the string-puller. The turn: Jim saves Silver's life because he still needs him. Critics at 11 percent — you stay for Oyelowo's pirate grin and the question of how long a boat can drift without wind.

Pros

  • David Oyelowo as Long John Silver: The Guardian calls him "mesmerising"; The Wall Street Journal sees him chewing scenery like hardtack — a pirate who can rock the boat alone.
  • Mom on deck instead of at the quay: Hayley Atwell as Bess Hawkins and Jack Huston as British spy bring new factions into the race for Flint's gold.
  • Ambition under full sail: The Hollywood Reporter credits "admirable ambition," Radio Times a "handsome adventure" — only the wind is missing.

Cons

  • Rotten Tomatoes 11 percent from 9 reviews. Irish Independent: "This Treasure Island is a shipwreck."
  • Metacritic 47: RogerEbert.com sees the source stretched "as thin as a pirate's blade"; Screen Rant speaks of predictable filler.
  • The Hollywood Reporter: execution "flat and repetitive and ultimately rather dreary" — IMDb average just 5.1.

Worst-of lists · Explorer