The Witcher: Season 4
WorstWatchers score: 55/100 – higher = worse
New Geralt, old armor — and the audience draws its sword.
Netflix swaps the Witcher: season four casts Liam Hemsworth as Geralt of Rivia after Henry Cavill swung the sword for three seasons. Geralt rides out with bard Jaskier, archer Milva, and vampire barber Regis — Laurence Fishburne — to find Ciri. She meanwhile runs with the Rats outlaw band while bounty hunter Leo Bonhart (Sharlto Copley) hunts her. Yennefer rallies sorceresses against rogue mage Vilgefortz. The base is Sapkowski's Baptism of Fire and The Tower of the Swallow, spread across eight episodes that dropped October 30, 2025. The turn: critics nodded half-friendly; audiences gave the new Geralt the cold shoulder.
Pros
- Hemsworth fares better than feared: Collider says he makes Geralt his own over eight episodes; IGN calls the result "good (enough)."
- Yennefer cleans up: Paste praises her largely invented arc as "fantastic"; IGN calls it the season's best strand.
- Trash with dignity: The Telegraph sees the season "just about" carried by pure silliness, plus Laurence Fishburne as vampire Regis (Polygon).
Cons
- Audience revolt: Rotten Tomatoes Audience only 19 percent from over 2,500 ratings, Metacritic users 1.8 from 323 scores.
- Per Polygon, the weakest Rotten Tomatoes launch of the main series, including scenes where Cavill's Geralt was patched over with Hemsworth inserts.
- Slashfilm ranks season 4 the franchise's weakest chapter yet; RogerEbert.com sees the series running out of breath.