The Swan
WorstWatchers score: 75/100 – higher = worse
Plastic surgery as a contest — the ugly duckling is the format.
The Fox show ran for 18 episodes in 2004 and put women who considered themselves unattractive through drastic makeovers of plastic surgery, diet, training, and therapy. For three months the contestants were not allowed to look in a mirror. In the end the transformed women competed against each other in a beauty pageant. Amanda Byram hosted, and the title nods to the fairy tale of the ugly duckling. Despite high ratings of around nine million viewers, it drew heavy criticism for the body image it promoted.
Pros
- High ratings of around nine million viewers (Wikipedia).
- Per Wikipedia most contestants later voiced satisfaction.
- A case study in the excesses of 2000s reality TV.
Cons
- IMDb only 2.5.
- Criticized for promoting a negative body image for women (Wikipedia).
- The Guardian: the winner is whoever looks least like her former self.