The Strangers: Chapter 2

2025 Movie Horror, Thriller

WorstWatchers score: 64/100 – higher = worse

Masks on, tension off — only the wild boar gives its all.

Maya barely survived the knife attack from Chapter 1 and wakes in the hospital of backwater Venus, Oregon, where the sheriff would rather sweep her story under the rug. Once night falls, Scarecrow, Dollface, and Pin-Up Girl stalk the halls and chase her from the morgue through a horse farm deep into the woods. There Maya stitches her own wounds and has to take down a runaway wild boar for good measure. Flashbacks interrupt to show how schoolkids became a killer trio. Renny Harlin shot all three chapters back-to-back in Slovakia in 2022; an extra week of childhood flashbacks was later bolted onto this middle chapter. The turn: an ambulance crashed on purpose flings Pin-Up Girl through the windshield — and then the screen just says "to be continued."

Pros

  • Beast-mode highlight: Maya wrestles a wild boar in the woods (Wikipedia); a Metacritic user calls it pure padding — Paste credits the film with stretches of a "dreamlike state of divine ridiculousness."
  • Madelaine Petsch holds the whole thing together: The New York Times tags her a "sneakily resilient scream queen," Looper calls the pivot into survival thriller "a breath of fresh air."
  • Praise with a warning label: TheWrap and Slashfilm call it an improvement on Chapter 1 — TheWrap compares that to mild food poisoning instead of severe.

Cons

  • Rotten Tomatoes just 15 percent from 74 reviews, audience 54 percent, Metacritic 28, users 3.7, Letterboxd 1.80/5, and CinemaScore C−.
  • The RT consensus brands it "a tired and tensionless slog" with lazy shocks; RogerEbert.com sees a "cash grab" that goes nowhere.
  • The reshot childhood flashbacks slow the pace, per Little White Lies, and turn the killers into "Strangers" without strangeness; Slashfilm says that erases the franchise's core.

Worst-of lists · Explorer