The Spirit
WorstWatchers score: 67/100 – higher = worse
Frank Miller paints Will Eisner's hero in black, white, and blood red — and forgets only the heart, the plot, and the fun.
Frank Miller alone adapted Will Eisner's comic classic: Gabriel Macht plays Denny Colt, a supposedly dead cop who leaps across Central City rooftops as the masked Spirit and shrugs off wounds like mosquito bites. His archenemy the Octopus (Samuel L. Jackson) wants immortality via the blood of Hercules with assistant Silken Floss (Scarlett Johansson), but in a crate heist grabs the Golden Fleece instead, which Colt's childhood love, master thief Sand Saref (Eva Mendes), is after. Between swaps, cloned henchmen, and a death angel named Lorelei who wants Colt back, the film increasingly loses the thread. Rotten Tomatoes counts only fourteen percent positive, Metacritic gives 30, and worldwide just $38.4 million came in. Empire ranked it 32nd among the worst films ever in 2010. Salon put it in a formula Eisner might have liked: the style was willing, but the Spirit was weak.
Pros
- Even the pan consensus grants the look: "its visuals are unique" (Rotten Tomatoes).
- Claudia Puig found "some amusing, escapist fun" in the campy adventure (USA Today, Metacritic).
- Chris Barsanti called it "one of the year's most refreshingly fun films" (Filmcritic.com, Wikipedia).
Cons
- Roger Ebert gave one of four stars: calling the characters cardboard insults useful packing material (Wikipedia).
- Only 14 percent from 114 reviews; the plot is "almost incomprehensible" (Rotten Tomatoes).
- U.S. gross only $19.8 million; Variety estimated losses in the tens of millions (Wikipedia).