The Sims 4: Enchanted by Nature

2025 Game Simulation

WorstWatchers score: 49/100 – higher = worse

Fairy dust, herbal tea, and a plague from the public restroom.

The 19th expansion pack for The Sims 4 adds fairies as a playable life state, the lush world of Innisgreen, natural living, apothecary potions, and a Naturopath career. Fairies shrink to toy size, fly instead of run, and per Screen Rant can break up a marriage with a single spell. Its centrepiece was meant to be the Ailments system: conditions that appear depending on a Sim's inner balance. The twist: the ailments spread like a plague — per EA, Sims caught one every day on average, even from public toilets, and witnessing a death instantly threw them off balance. Less than three weeks after the July 10, 2025 release, a patch cut the plague by up to 75 percent, and a later toggle switched off contagion entirely. Critics gave it a respectable 74 on Metacritic, while only 43 percent of Steam user reviews were positive.

Pros

  • Critics are spellbound: GameSpot and ComicBook each give it 90/100, and GameSpot calls it a rare Sims 4 pack that feels like a complete experience.
  • Fairy mischief with bite: per Screen Rant a single spell can break up a marriage, per ComicBook fairies shrink down to play in household items.
  • Innisgreen as a backdrop: GameSpot praises the "wonderful new world", ScreenHub its lovely charm.

Cons

  • Steam just 43 percent positive, Metacritic user score 1.6.
  • Ailment plague: per EA's patch notes Sims fell ill every day on average, even from public toilets — only a patch (up to 75 percent fewer) and later an off switch helped (EA, KeenGamer, Wikipedia).
  • Nature gets short shrift: Gameliner calls the nature side flat, IGN Benelux the nature content minimal, and Digital Spy doubts it justifies a full expansion pack.

Worst-of lists · Explorer