The Playboy Club
WorstWatchers score: 55/100 – higher = worse
Mad Men with bunny ears — shot down after three episodes.
Chicago, 1961: in the first Playboy Club the "Bunnies" serve cocktails while lawyer Nick Dalton sets the tone with mafia contacts and political plans. Right at the start new Bunny Maureen kills a mafia boss in self-defense, and Dalton rushes to help. The series wants emancipation, glamour, and crime at once. Conservatives called for a boycott before launch; Gloria Steinem too. The turn: in the end it was not the moral lobby that killed the show but ratings — NBC canceled it after three aired episodes, the season's first cancellation.
Pros
- Production design and '60s look are solid per TVLine; Laura Benanti was praised.
- A subplot about the gay Mattachine Society struck AfterElton as surprisingly successful.
- Read as a camp soap the thing has entertainment value — exactly what NPR recommended.
Cons
- NPR found the pilot "silly and full of bad dialogue", kitschier than offensive.
- Entertainment Weekly accused the series of shamelessly cribbing Mad Men.
- Too tame for the subject, too suggestive for critics — the Hollywood Reporter simply called it a bad show.