The Perfect Man

2005 Movie Comedy, Romance

WorstWatchers score: 65/100 – higher = worse

Fake dating dad via chat — critics send regrets.

Hilary Duff invents the perfect man for her mother and must keep the lie running. Mid-2000s teen comedy with a predictable happy ending. The turn: only the marketing slogan was perfect.

Pros

  • Duff star power for the target audience (Wikipedia).
  • Light fare without edge.
  • Nostalgic as a Y2K teen flop.

Cons

  • Critics found plot and gags thin (Rotten Tomatoes).
  • Romcom formulas without surprise.
  • Little shelf life beyond the fanbase.

Worst-of lists · Explorer