The Old Guard 2
WorstWatchers score: 59/100 – higher = worse
Immortal heroes, mortally dull exposition — and Uma Thurman as a subscription bonus.
Off the coast of Rome, an iron maiden is hauled up from the seabed – inside is Quỳnh (Veronica Ngô), an immortal who spent 500 years locked away underwater. Meanwhile Andy (Charlize Theron) and her crew raid weapons caches from Split to Seoul, where the sage Tuah (Henry Golding) reveals that the chronicles of every immortal have been stolen. Behind the theft is Discord (Uma Thurman), the very first immortal, now an arms dealer. The twist: Nile (KiKi Layne) is the last immortal and can strip others of their immortality with a single wound – exactly what Discord wants to exploit. The showdown takes place at a nuclear plant in South Tangerang, where Booker sacrifices himself and Discord escapes with Andy's comrades. Directed by Victoria Mahoney and released on Netflix on July 2, 2025, it ends on a pure cliffhanger for part three.
Pros
- Charlize Theron holds it all together: TheWrap says the film may not live forever, but her badassery might.
- Per The Hollywood Reporter it is well acted, with enough action for most appetites and a melancholy streak about conflicted superheroes.
- More lore, bigger cast: The New York Times praises how Uma Thurman, Henry Golding and Veronica Ngô broaden the comic-book world.
Cons
- Rotten Tomatoes 27 percent, audience 33 percent, Metascore 44, IMDb 5.1.
- Rotten Tomatoes consensus: bogged down by tedious lore and lackluster execution, the budding franchise already feels long in the tooth.
- Collider sees nothing but setup for part three, scene after scene of exposition and little fighting; IGN misses a real Theron-versus-Thurman showdown.