The New Normal

2012 Series Comedy

WorstWatchers score: 38/100 – higher = worse

Two dads, one surrogate, one grandma from hell — Ryan Murphy cranks it up.

Bryan (Andrew Rannells) and David (Justin Bartha) are a wealthy gay couple in Los Angeles who only lack a baby to be happy. Enter Goldie (Georgia King), a waitress from Ohio who has left her cheating husband and wants to start over with her nine-year-old daughter Shania. She becomes their surrogate and moves in. In tow: Goldie's arch-conservative grandmother Jane (Ellen Barkin), who wreaks havoc. Ryan Murphy and Ali Adler wrote the NBC sitcom, which ran for one season in 2012–13.

Pros

  • Rotten Tomatoes: heartfelt and briskly paced.
  • USA Today called it a surprisingly touching comedy (Wikipedia).
  • Ellen Barkin as the acid-tongued grandmother (Wikipedia, Metacritic).

Cons

  • Rotten Tomatoes 51 percent, Metascore 61.
  • Rotten Tomatoes: one-dimensional characters and jarring tonal shifts.
  • New York Daily News: it wants what Modern Family is having — a bumpy ride (Wikipedia).

Worst-of lists · Explorer