The Haunting of Molly Hartley

2008 Movie Horror

WorstWatchers score: 71/100 – higher = worse

Satanic pact at private school, scary as a parents' evening.

In The Haunting of Molly Hartley, 17-year-old Molly, played by Haley Bennett, is stabbed by her confused mother with scissors and survives. Her father sends her to a new private school, but as her 18th birthday nears she is haunted by nightmares and hallucinations. Classmate Joseph, played by Gossip Girl star Chace Crawford, wants to help; others seem to know exactly what is wrong with her. Finally an old pact is revealed: Molly died as a baby, her parents sold her soul to the devil, due on her 18th birthday. The turn: the devout classmate wants to save her by baptism — and nearly drowns her doing it.

Pros

  • Decider found in 2018 it was exactly the film for a night with friends who want to laugh at "hot teenagers do batshit stuff" (Wikipedia).
  • Young cast before the breakthrough: Haley Bennett, Chace Crawford, and AnnaLynne McCord (Wikipedia).
  • Not a total box-office wipeout: fifth place opening weekend at Halloween (Wikipedia).

Cons

  • Rotten Tomatoes 3 percent: "a rather lifeless horror endeavor, with a pedestrian plot and few scares".
  • The Hollywood Reporter: a teen horror that "wouldn't pass muster on the CW network" (Wikipedia).
  • The A.V. Club gave a D+: "better suited for skittish cats than humans" (Wikipedia).

Worst-of lists · Explorer