Teen Mom

2009 Series Reality

WorstWatchers score: 60/100 – higher = worse

Motherhood as a soap opera — babies run as extras.

Teen Mom is the first spin-off of 16 and Pregnant and from December 2009 follows four young mothers from season one: Maci Bookout, Catelynn Lowell, Amber Portwood, and Farrah Abraham. Cameras are there as they juggle school, job, and baby and fight with partners, parents, and exes. What was meant as a look at the hard reality of early parenthood quickly became a tabloid machine. Amber Portwood especially made headlines after TV showed her hitting partner Gary while the crew simply kept filming. The turn: only viewers alerted authorities, and Portwood was charged with domestic violence — with footage from her own show.

Pros

  • Common Sense Media praises a "non-glamorized look" at young parents' reality that could open teenagers' eyes.
  • Ratings hit: season two ended per Wikipedia with over 5.6 million viewers.
  • A Metacritic critic found the show "Still absorbing. Still painful." — both true.

Cons

  • Per Wikipedia MTV did not intervene when Portwood beat her partner on camera; only viewers brought in police.
  • A Metacritic critic: the show became a soap about "looking for love in all the wrong places", "The babies are mere window dressing".
  • An Indiana University study found per Wikipedia that regular viewers got an unrealistic picture of teen pregnancy.

Worst-of lists · Explorer