Surrogates

2009 Movie Action, Sci-Fi

WorstWatchers score: 49/100 – higher = worse

Bruce Willis with a toupee robot saves humanity from the couch.

In Jonathan Mostow's Surrogates humanity lives almost only through remote-controlled, flawless robot bodies while real people sit unwashed at home in their chairs. When two surrogate users die because a new weapon fries their robots and thus also the operators, FBI agent Tom Greer, played by Bruce Willis with a smooth blond mop as his robo-self, investigates. The trail leads to Lionel Canter, inventor of the surrogates, to a reserve of radical machine opponents under a prophet (Ving Rhames), and into Greer's own agency. After his surrogate is destroyed, Greer must for the first time in years step outside in his own vulnerable body. The turn: in the end the hero of all people gets to decide whether all robot bodies worldwide are shut down — and he hits the button.

Pros

  • Entertainment Weekly found "fun robot stuff, some good philosophical ideas" and an odd Willis–Rhames reunion after Pulp Fiction (Wikipedia, Metacritic).
  • Roger Ebert gave two and a half stars and called the film "entertaining and ingenious" — before it fled too quickly into formula (Wikipedia).
  • The premise of living by avatar feels more current today than in 2009, and even the Rotten Tomatoes consensus praises the glossy look.

Cons

  • Rotten Tomatoes only 37 percent: "fails to capitalize on a promising premise, relying instead on mindless action and a poor script" (Wikipedia).
  • A Metacritic critic asks whether the actors sound so robotic because they play robots well or humans badly — "did a machine write this dialogue?"
  • Not screened for critics in advance and disappointing at the box office: about $122 million worldwide on an $80 million budget (Wikipedia).

Worst-of lists · Explorer