Summerwater

2025 Series Drama, Mystery

WorstWatchers score: 59/100 – higher = worse

White Lotus in drizzle — minus the lotus.

A holiday park on a Scottish loch, five cabins, drizzle: after a party night something burns, and somewhere there is a body. Then the series rewinds and retells the same 24 hours cabin by cabin — jogger Justine with a bad heart, GP David (Dougray Scott) with his dementia-stricken wife Annie (Shirley Henderson), two bored teens with no Wi-Fi. In the middle, an Eastern European couple from the hotel whose hardcore house music frays every nerve. The turn: the title nods to an old ballad where a whole village is punished because nobody helped an old man — and the lakeside neighbors are that helpful. Press dubbed it "Scotland's White Lotus" — you stay to see who holds the match first.

Pros

  • Acting against the rain: The Herald calls Dougray Scott and Shirley Henderson "outstanding"; even The Telegraph finds Scott "always watchable."
  • Gloom in a pretty package: The Irish Times calls it "well made," The Herald "weird and all kinds of wonderful" — loch, cabins, and permanent grey in abundance.
  • Not a crime-by-numbers: The Guardian praises the attempt to dodge "crime mysteries powered by buried secrets"; The Herald the puzzle of perspectives all racing toward the same fire.

Cons

  • Rotten Tomatoes 27 percent from 11 reviews, Metacritic 40 — all four Metacritic reviews land at "mixed," IMDb just 5.1.
  • Too slow, too dark: The Telegraph calls it "too slow, too sombre," The Times "really quite depressing," The Irish Times sees Withnail and I without the humor.
  • Melodrama instead of plot: The Guardian sees "melodramatic acting at the expense of narrative substance"; Decider a series that digs in broken heads instead of pushing the story.

Worst-of lists · Explorer