Star Search

2026 Series Castingshow, Live

WorstWatchers score: 50/100 – higher = worse

The judges searched for stars — and found only notebooks.

Netflix brings back the '80s talent show, live and worldwide: host Anthony Anderson presents singers, dancers, comedians and magicians, judged by Sarah Michelle Gellar, Jelly Roll and Chrissy Teigen. Viewers vote in real time with one to five stars via remote, and the average counts as a fourth judge. The nine episodes ran from January 20 to February 17, 2026; the finale was decided by viewers alone — magician TJ Salta won. Reality Blurred hailed the voting tech as a miracle but called the judging panel the real misfire. Jelly Roll admitted of a dance group that he is "so not qualified to judge any kind of movement". The twist: the show's best judge was the remote control.

Pros

  • Reality Blurred: live voting via remote is a "technical marvel".
  • Per Reality Blurred, Anthony Anderson hosts with ease.
  • Netflix Tudum: viewers decide the finale entirely on their own.

Cons

  • IMDb 4.3.
  • Reality Blurred: the judges are "the real embarrassment", critiques without substance.
  • Overlong intro packages, barely any acts in the first half hour (Reality Blurred).

Worst-of lists · Explorer