Simon Cowell: The Next Act

2025 Series Reality, Music, Documentary

WorstWatchers score: 55/100 – higher = worse

Cowell hunts a boy band and mostly finds himself.

Simon Cowell wants to pull another boy band out of thin air and films himself doing it. Auditions, house, gut feeling, six episodes on Netflix. The Telegraph calls it so dated the last twenty years might as well not have happened. The Guardian sees the boys as an afterthought; the star remains Cowell. The Times finds the castings dull and the man in front more interesting. You stay because the vanity here is not an accident — it is the product.

Pros

  • The vanity is not an accident; it is the show. Cowell knows that and plays along.
  • The Times finds the castings dull and the man in front more interesting. Correct.
  • Six episodes, one gut feeling, one empty stool: reality in pure form.

Cons

  • The Telegraph: so dated the last twenty years might as well not have happened.
  • The Guardian: the boys doing the work are the afterthought.
  • 25 percent with critics, Metascore 36. The boy band stays a footnote.

Worst-of lists · Explorer