Shadowbane
WorstWatchers score: 38/100 – higher = worse
Build castles, raze castles — until the servers got razed.
Shadowbane was released by Ubisoft in March 2003, developed by Wolfpack Studios. The online role-playing game went all in on player-versus-player combat: guilds built their own cities and could besiege and burn down others'. Players, not the company, decided war and peace. At launch it was a top-10 PC seller; in 2006 it went free-to-play and was later funded by ads shown when a character died. A 2008 reboot wiped all characters and cities, and in July 2009 the servers shut down for good.
Pros
- "Generally favorable" on Metacritic (Wikipedia).
- A pioneer of open PvP worlds and siege warfare (Wikipedia).
- Over 120,000 copies sold by the end of March 2003 (Wikipedia).
Cons
- The Rise of Chaos expansion got only mixed reviews (Wikipedia).
- Ads on character death to fund operations (Wikipedia).
- The 2008 reboot wiped all characters and cities; it ended in 2009 (Wikipedia).