The Secret Diary of Desmond Pfeiffer
WorstWatchers score: 80/100 – higher = worse
An English nobleman as Lincoln's valet – cancelled after three weeks.
Black English nobleman Desmond Pfeiffer (Chi McBride) flees gambling debts in Britain and becomes valet to President Abraham Lincoln (Dann Florek). In a Civil War-era White House full of drunks and louts, he is the only intelligent, erudite presence. Even before launch, African-American groups including the Los Angeles NAACP protested its perceived light-hearted take on slavery; UPN replaced the pilot with another episode. The sitcom ran from October 5 to 26, 1998, and its first episode ranked 116th of 125 programmes that week. David Hofstede listed it among the "100 Dumbest Events in Television History", while noting that it showed no slaves and was meant to satirise the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal. Entertainment Weekly ranked it fifth among its Top 50 TV Bombs.
Pros
- Chi McBride as a commanding centre.
- Intended as a satire of the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal.
- A curious chapter in TV history.
Cons
- Juvenile sexual humour, per Hofstede.
- Disastrous ratings.
- Entertainment Weekly: fifth-biggest TV bomb.