Scar-Lead Salvation

2025 Game Action, Shooter

WorstWatchers score: 56/100 – higher = worse

Returnal from the bargain bin — endless corridors, zero variety.

Willow wakes with no memory in a military facility and shoots through robot hordes on a roguelike clock. Compile Heart and Neilo deliver a third-person shooter in a Returnal costume for PS5, PC, and later Xbox. Metacritic files the PS5 version under "generally unfavorable"; OpenCritic reaches only 5 percent recommendations. Hardcore Gamer sees "bones for a good game" that somehow never become fun; Digitally Downloaded criticizes interchangeable metal rooms and repeated enemy types. The shooting bangs sometimes; the loops bore faster than a loading screen. You stay for individual bosses — and quit the run before the next corridor starts.

Pros

  • Hardcore Gamer concedes the raw material is there: "The bones for a good game are there" (Hardcore Gamer via Wikipedia).
  • As pure shooter core: ballistics and boss fights are not completely discarded even in pans (Wikipedia).
  • Multiplatform release including a later Xbox launch — at least reachability is covered (Wikipedia).

Cons

  • OpenCritic: only 5 percent of critics recommend the game (Wikipedia).
  • Metacritic rates the PS5 version "generally unfavorable" (Wikipedia).
  • Digitally Downloaded: square metal rooms and enemy types repeat too often (Wikipedia).

Worst-of lists · Explorer