S. Darko

2009 Movie Sci-Fi, Thriller

WorstWatchers score: 73/100 – higher = worse

Donnie Darko's little sister — the rabbit should have warned her better.

S. Darko is set seven years after Donnie Darko's death and follows his sister Samantha, again played by Daveigh Chase. She sleepwalks, has visions, and hits the road toward California with best friend Corey. In the small town of Conejo Springs their car breaks down, a boy is missing, and a meteorite smashes into a windmill. Richard Kelly, creator of the original, was not involved; it arrived in 2009 straight to DVD and Blu-ray. The turn: Kelly later said he had never seen the film and never would.

Pros

  • Daveigh Chase returns as Samantha — the only real link to the cult film (Wikipedia).
  • The Washington Post at least recommended fans watch the making-of and commentary instead of the film itself.
  • Richard Kelly's rant about the sequel is almost more entertaining than the film (Wikipedia).

Cons

  • Rotten Tomatoes 13 percent from 8 reviews.
  • The A.V. Club gave an F: a few surface elements of Donnie Darko and a spectacularly failed franchise attempt.
  • Critics per Wikipedia faulted a muddled plot, one-dimensional characters, and superficial dialogue.

Worst-of lists · Explorer