Proven Innocent

2019 Series Drama, Crime

WorstWatchers score: 48/100 – higher = worse

A lawyer fights wrongful convictions — critics hand down one on the show.

As a teenager, Madeline Scott (Rachelle Lefevre) spent ten years in prison for a murder she didn't commit, along with her brother Levi. Now she runs a small Chicago firm dedicated to freeing the wrongfully convicted. Her nemesis is state's attorney Gore Bellows (Kelsey Grammer), whose career rests on exactly such dubious convictions, including her own. Fox premiered David Elliot's legal drama in February 2019 and cancelled it in May after one season. Rotten Tomatoes finds it guilty on all counts: clunky dialogue, stale contrivances, rote formula.

Pros

  • A strong cast with Kelsey Grammer and Vincent Kartheiser (Wikipedia).
  • An important subject: wrongful convictions and their aftermath (TVMaze).
  • Personal stakes through Madeline's own imprisonment (Wikipedia).

Cons

  • Rotten Tomatoes 26 percent, Metascore 47.
  • Rotten Tomatoes: clunky dialogue and stale plot contrivances.
  • Cancelled after one season (Wikipedia).

Worst-of lists · Explorer