Practical Magic 2
WorstWatchers score: 55/100 – higher = worse
Witch sisters return — B+ audiences; critics only lukewarm enchanted.
Practical Magic 2 (2026) continues the witch-family material with Susanne Bier. Rotten Tomatoes around 36 percent, Metacritic 44, CinemaScore B+. Romcom fantasy for fans of the original; reviewers saw formula without freshness. You stay out of sister nostalgia.
Pros
- CinemaScore B+ — fanbase present (Wikipedia).
- Continuation of familiar witch chemistry (Wikipedia).
- Metacritic 44 near middling (Metacritic).
Cons
- Tomatometer around 36 percent (Rotten Tomatoes).
- Critics: lukewarm, little new (Wikipedia).
- Source formula dominates (Wikipedia).