Paul American
WorstWatchers score: 65/100 – higher = worse
Two brothers, zero filter, eight episodes of nonstop noise.
YouTube brothers Logan and Jake Paul let the cameras into their lives: a boxing match with Mike Tyson, WWE appearances, an engagement, baby plans, and their business empire of drinks, grooming products, and fight promotion. Along for the ride are father Greg Paul, Nina Agdal, and speed skater Jutta Leerdam, with cameos from KSI and MrBeast. The eight episodes premiered on Max on March 27, 2025. Per Variety, the show mistakes volume for star quality and is an ordeal for anyone outside the fanbase; Vulture mostly finds it boring. The twist: it's a show about making the show — including a fight that blows up right while pitching "loving brothers".
Pros
- For Paul fans it's an unfiltered look behind the Tyson fight and the WWE appearances.
- Per Variety, Jutta Leerdam delivers the only grounded moment when she asks Jake to "be a real person".
- The brothers' blow-up right in the middle of pitching a show about "loving brothers" is unintentionally funny.
Cons
- IMDb rating just 2.8/10, Rotten Tomatoes Popcornmeter at 48%.
- Variety calls the show "repellent and noxiously loud" — unbearable for anyone outside the fanbase.
- Vulture: the series thinks it's controversial, but it's just boring.