Other Mommy

2026 Movie Horror, Mystery, Thriller

WorstWatchers score: 57/100 – higher = worse

Chastain plays Mom twice — and the closet is more scared than you are.

Seven-year-old Bella sees a second mother in her closet — Other Mommy, who asks to be let "into her heart." While Ursula builds a career and Russ runs the house, the entity grows with the marriage war: party guests vanish, Frank is carved up in front of the family, a lake under a villa swallows Bella into a giant hand. Grandma Ruth and a ghost hunter are powerless; in the basement Ursula admits she never wanted Bella — and that is exactly what weakens Other Mommy. Bella fights the pain-relief lie, beats the demon, and months later hangs Christmas lights. Only: Ursula's discontent returns. Rob Savage, Blumhouse, and Jessica Chastain deliver jump-scare prestige trash with CinemaScore D+ — you stay for the dual role and the question whether motherly love really wins the basement.

Pros

  • Jessica Chastain as Ursula and Other Mommy: star power and closet monster in one dual role the trailer promises.
  • Blumhouse/Atomic Monster jump scares and 4DX-ready camera moves deliver short shock bursts between the family kitsch.
  • CinemaScore D+ on a $27.8 million opening: audience and critics feud nicely — box-office flop tension included.

Cons

  • Rotten Tomatoes 16 percent. Consensus: too silly for the jump scares to cohere into something scary.
  • Metacritic 39. Variety calls it one of the limpest works of the year — tone completely off.
  • Letterboxd around 2.3 and IMDb 5.5: even genre fans land under the horror average.

Worst-of lists · Explorer