Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story

2026 Series Crime, Drama, Horror

WorstWatchers score: 51/100 – higher = worse

The axe is sharp; the script is dull.

Fall River, 1892: Lizzie Borden smothers in the house of her stingy father Andrew (Charlie Hunnam) and imperious stepmother Abby (Rebecca Hall). Then a new Irish maid arrives whom Abby simply calls "Maggie," and curiosity becomes a secret affair. When Abby kills Lizzie's beloved pigeons, the axe is only a matter of scheduling. Netflix throws in detours to Elisabeth Báthory and Sarah Paulson as Aileen Wuornos before the trial of the century. The turn: acquittal, inheritance, a new life — and Lizzie still sits alone in the big house. You stay for the "most glamorous butchery" The Telegraph has ever seen.

Pros

  • Luxury slaughter: The Telegraph sees "the most glamorous butchery I have ever seen on screen"; Variety calls the season "refreshing and wholly unique" in the Monster canon.
  • Strong ensemble in corsets: The Guardian especially praises Rebecca Hall's Abby; RogerEbert.com and Critical Registrar praise cast and production design.
  • Ratings despite the hangover: number one on Netflix's global charts with 12.1 million views in four days — per Comicbasics now past 80 million.

Cons

  • Rotten Tomatoes 35 percent from 31 reviews, Metacritic 47 — the RT consensus calls the season an "ill-fitted, uninspiring new rendition" with nothing interesting to say.
  • The A.V. Club (42) finds "no clear point"; Collider sees a mix of lecture and fairy tale; IGN calls it "too scattershot and tonally inconsistent."
  • Audience spiral: IMDb season average 6.4 (Dahmer 7.9, Ed Gein 6.9), episode 8 just 5.3 — plus RT Popcornmeter 32 and Metacritic users 4.0.

Worst-of lists · Explorer