Missing You

2025 Series Thriller, Crime, Drama

WorstWatchers score: 49/100 – higher = worse

Missing for eleven years, then a match — and instantly blocked.

Detective Inspector Kat Donovan (Rosalind Eleazar) swipes through a dating app and lands on Josh (Ashley Walters) – the fiancé who vanished without a trace eleven years ago. Josh promptly blocks her, while Kat chases missing-persons cases that lead to a catfishing ring: dog breeder Titus (Steve Pemberton) lures widowed singles with fake profiles built from old Facebook photos and bleeds them dry. Meanwhile the murder of Kat's father Clint (Lenny Henry), confessed to by a terminally ill prisoner, keeps gnawing at her. The Harlan Coben adaptation premiered on Netflix on New Year's Day 2025, with Richard Armitage and James Nesbitt along for the ride. The twist: Clint led a years-long double life, and Kat's own boss covered up the truth about his death. One twist chases the next — whether they fit together is beside the point.

Pros

  • Non-stop twists: Collider calls it extremely bingeable, The Mercury News praises "surprise after surprise", and The Guardian ends up "wholly addicted".
  • Steve Pemberton as a dog breeder with a kidnapping side hustle — an "insidious dog snob" per Netflix Tudum, the head of a criminal operation per Wikipedia.
  • Rosalind Eleazar carries it: Paste praises her great performance, The Telegraph the emotional depth of her scenes with Ashley Walters.

Cons

  • Rotten Tomatoes 50 percent with critics and just 31 with audiences, Metascore 56, IMDb 6.1.
  • The Independent finds it "too stupid and too manipulative", Decider warns of twists that will have you shaking your head.
  • Overstuffed plot: The Mercury News says you practically need a road map, The A.V. Club sees two different shows, The Wall Street Journal a tangle of loose threads.

Worst-of lists · Explorer