Michael Jackson: The Verdict
WorstWatchers score: 50/100 – higher = worse
Twelve weeks of trial, two and a half hours of documentary, zero new revelations.
Director Nick Green's three-part Netflix documentary revisits the 2005 criminal trial of Michael Jackson, which ended after twelve weeks with an acquittal on all charges. Because cameras were not allowed in the courtroom, the Candle True Stories production relies on interviews with jurors, trial reporters, prosecutor Ron Zonen and defense attorney Mark Geragos, plus archival footage. Journalist Martin Bashir and Jackson biographer J. Randy Taraborrelli also weigh in. The twist: critics such as Slate and Decider find barely anything new in roughly two and a half hours, and The Telegraph says the subject has simply been rendered dull by endless repetition. Even so, Netflix reports 17.8 million viewers in the first five days and the number one spot in 61 countries. While critics on Rotten Tomatoes are mostly kind, the audience score there crashes to 8 percent.
Pros
- Thoroughly researched: Variety praises how it unpacks the ins and outs of the three-month trial, and the Rotten Tomatoes consensus calls it one of the clearest explorations.
- A strong interview roster with jurors, prosecutor Ron Zonen, defense attorney Mark Geragos and Martin Bashir (Wikipedia); The Telegraph finds that guest list the most interesting part.
- Per Slate it guides viewers through the case with a steady hand – for anyone curious about what the biopic "Michael" left out.
Cons
- Rotten Tomatoes audience just 8 percent, Metacritic user score 1.5, IMDb 5.0.
- Nothing new: Slate finds barely anything you have not heard before, and Decider calls the series completely unnecessary.
- USA Today sees more spectacle than revelation, The Telegraph an unsettling story rendered dull by endless repetition.