Material Girls

2006 Movie Comedy

WorstWatchers score: 77/100 – higher = worse

Hilary and Haylie Duff as heirs in trouble — the material is paper-thin, and so is the wit.

Material Girls (2006) plunges two spoiled sisters into image ruin and self-discovery. Rotten Tomatoes: 4 percent, Metacritic: 17; consensus: paper-thin characterizations, hackneyed script. Rom-com formula without spark. You stay out of Duff nostalgia.

Pros

  • Hilary and Haylie Duff sibling chemistry (Wikipedia).
  • Light feel-good premise for a teen target audience (Wikipedia).
  • Fashion and L.A. glamour as visual appeal (Wikipedia).

Cons

  • RT consensus: paper-thin characters, hackneyed script (Rotten Tomatoes).
  • Metacritic 17/100 (Metacritic).
  • Only 4 percent Tomatometer (Rotten Tomatoes).

Worst-of lists · Explorer