Marshals
WorstWatchers score: 49/100 – higher = worse
Yellowstone without the ranch — badge instead of drama, procedural instead of powder keg.
Kayce Dutton hangs up the ranch and joins the U.S. Marshals in Montana. Taylor Sheridan's family epic becomes a weekly neo-Western case show at CBS with horses and widower pathos. Rotten Tomatoes hits 45 percent; the consensus speaks of a dull procedural without Yellowstone's spark; Metacritic lands at 57. The Daily Beast calls fights and shootouts CBS-grade lackluster; Variety sees only a passing family resemblance to the mother show. Still, over nine million watched the premiere — the brand pulls even without a ranch. You stay because Luke Grimes looks so stoic Montana might be paying him for it.
Pros
- 9.52 million viewers at the premiere — appetite for Duttons is measurable (Wikipedia).
- Metacritic 57/100 at least signals average instead of total wreck (Metacritic).
- Luke Grimes, Brecken Merrill, and company continue the Yellowstone characters — continuity for franchise fans (Wikipedia).
Cons
- RT consensus: Marshals forces Kayce into a procedural without Yellowstone's spark (Rotten Tomatoes).
- Daily Beast: fights, chases, and shootouts are "CBS-grade lackluster" (The Daily Beast).
- Variety sees only a "passing family resemblance" to Yellowstone and the sibling shows (Variety).