The Lord of the Rings: Conquest
WorstWatchers score: 50/100 – higher = worse
Battlefront in Middle-earth costume, only without love of detail.
The Lord of the Rings: Conquest launched in January 2009 at EA from the team behind the first two Star Wars: Battlefront games. You fight as warrior, archer, mage, or scout through the big battles of the film trilogy, up to the siege of Minas Tirith, and later as a hero like Aragorn or Gandalf. A second campaign flips the script: Frodo fails, Sauron gets the Ring back and conquers Middle-earth. Hugo Weaving narrates; Howard Shore's film score plays. The turn: the best idea is precisely the what-if in which the Witch-king kills Frodo and evil wins.
Pros
- Even a Metacritic review praises the evil campaign: "we love being the bad guys".
- Real Howard Shore film music and Hugo Weaving as narrator (Wikipedia).
- IGN UK found the presentation captures the Middle-earth feel fairly well (Wikipedia).
Cons
- Game Informer called it "a joyless trip through familiar territories" (Wikipedia).
- Eurogamer found AI allies "AI-impoverished"; Game Informer felt they were on acid (Wikipedia).
- Per IGN button-mashing suffices; all classes play the same and heroes are only "class characters on steroids" (Wikipedia).