The Jay Leno Show
WorstWatchers score: 66/100 – higher = worse
NBC gave Leno primetime and got the biggest programming flop in its history.
The Jay Leno Show was NBC's attempt not to lose Jay Leno to rivals after he left The Tonight Show. From September 2009 he ran five nights a week at 10 p.m., with monologue, celebrity guests, the old "Headlines" and "Jaywalking" bits, plus the "Green Car Challenge" in which stars drove an electric Ford around a test track. The math: cheap to produce, so profitable even on middling ratings. But viewership fell, and the local news on NBC affiliates afterward collapsed with it. The turn: NBC wanted to push Leno back to 11:35; Conan O'Brien refused to host Tonight after midnight, bought himself out for a $45 million deal — and Leno got his old show back.
Pros
- The opener with Jerry Seinfeld and Jay-Z, Rihanna and Kanye West drew about 17.7 million viewers per Wikipedia.
- A Metacritic critic praised the "smart and smartass mix of talent and controversy".
- The Green Car Challenge, cribbed from Top Gear, was at least a new idea — Rush Limbaugh deliberately posted the worst time (Wikipedia).
Cons
- Entertainment Weekly ranked the show number one among the 50 biggest TV flops; TV Guide called it the greatest misstep in television history (Wikipedia).
- Metacritic 48: the Associated Press found the Bud Light spot funnier than the comedy it interrupted (Wikipedia).
- A Metacritic critic called it a "strange, shallow puddle of comedy" and "brand-old to the bone".