In the Hand of Dante
WorstWatchers score: 59/100 – higher = worse
Schnabel steals Dante's manuscript and loses the film along the way.
Nick Tosches is hired by a New York godfather to steal Dante's manuscript. In parallel Dante himself wanders the 14th century hunting the same sentence. Schnabel cuts both lives together until the heist becomes a symposium. Oscar Isaac carries the author; Gal Gadot and Gerard Butler appear as if casting rolled dice. The first two thirds still have momentum. Then the film frays and the big gesture stays bigger than the story.
Pros
- The double plot of author versus poet is so over-the-top you stay just to see who tips first.
- Butler in the Middle Ages is the punchline, not the supporting role.
- Schnabel swings big. Deadline names the swing even when it misses.
Cons
- RT consensus: bloated, slipping into farce, 30 percent from 54 reviews.
- Guardian: the last thirds lose the thread.
- Two hours thirty-three for a heist that turns into a seminar.