Ice Cream Man
WorstWatchers score: 66/100 – higher = worse
Eli Roth serves brain freeze with offal sprinkles.
Bayleen Bay, high summer: a mute ice cream man rolls into town with jingle music, and every kid who tastes his treats stares glassy-eyed at a cartoon afterward. At night the truck rings again — and the little ones turn on their parents. Only lactose-intolerant Jared and two friends ate nothing and flee, until they find a freezer full of ice cream in a church basement and a priest with secret knowledge. The turn: the helpful priest is the necromancer himself, and at the graveyard ritual the kids catch their own parents. Eli Roth founded his own horror label for this treat — you stay to see how deep he dips the cone.
Pros
- Gore without a diet: Film Threat calls it "depraved fun," The New York Times a blizzard cup of slapstick and stomach churn — splatter fans get the extra scoop.
- Roth's gleeful disgust: RogerEbert.com sees "undisguised glee"; The Hollywood Reporter calls it "sick and twisted" — and is sure Roth takes that as a compliment.
- Nasty scoop at the end: The A.V. Club calls the turn Roth's "most ruthlessly bleak work to date" — the ice cream man simply rolls on to the next town with his child army.
Cons
- Rotten Tomatoes 25 percent from 125 reviews, Metacritic 33 — the RT consensus speaks of half-melted social critique with no nutritional value under the gore.
- Knockoff soft serve: IGN (4/10) would rather have Terrifier or Weapons; Deadline sees a bad cheap imitation of Weapons; Empire gives one star.
- Audiences spit it out: Letterboxd 1.33, IMDb 4.0, Metacritic users 2.8 — and Roth had to admit some scenes used generative AI.