Holland
WorstWatchers score: 63/100 – higher = worse
Tulips, model trains, a serial killer — only the suspense never leaves the station.
Holland, Michigan, in 2000: teacher Nancy (Nicole Kidman) lives the perfect small-town life between tulip festival and front lawn with optometrist husband Fred (Matthew Macfadyen) and son Harry. Because Fred attends suspiciously many optometry conferences and hoards Polaroids without owning a Polaroid camera, she snoops after him with colleague Dave (Gael García Bernal) — and falls for him along the way. Then Nancy realizes that Fred's lovingly built model railway recreates crime scenes of murdered women. Mimi Cave directed the thriller from a script by Andrew Sodroski; after its SXSW premiere it went straight to Prime Video on March 27, 2025. Rotten Tomatoes' verdict: lots of style, but a hollow script full of recycled twists. The twist: a script that spent years on the Black List of best unproduced screenplays derails on its own model railway.
Pros
- Per TheWrap and Deadline, Nicole Kidman plays with sharp, almost manic energy.
- Variety praises the consistent point of view from Nancy's perspective.
- Rotten Tomatoes and Deadline highlight the striking, stylized look.
Cons
- Only 21% positive reviews on Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic 42.
- Per the critics consensus, overloaded with quirk and recycled twists.
- Audiences are even harsher: 24% Popcornmeter, Metacritic users 3.9.