Fire Emblem Shadows
WorstWatchers score: 54/100 – higher = worse
Fire Emblem meets Among Us and loses to the shop.
Nintendo shadow-drops Among Us with crests. Three disciples, one is the traitor, battles run themselves, the shop sells the win. GameSpot scores 3/10, Metacritic 37, Nintendo Life yawns over timers and pay-to-win. The cutscenes look like Fire Emblem; the game does not. You keep tapping because betrayal sounds so good on paper — and is over so fast on the screen.
Pros
- Character design and sound still feel like Fire Emblem. GameSpot leaves exactly that as a plus.
- Tricking others as a shadow is briefly fun — Koch admitted that over several evenings.
- The betrayal pitch on paper is so good you start the first round anyway.
Cons
- Metascore 37, GameSpot 3/10, Nintendo Life 4/10. Second-worst game of 2025 on Metacritic.
- Auto-combat without tactics, deduction without weight. Polygon and GameSpot describe the same idle loop.
- Microtransactions buy the win. The shop plays better than the traitor.