Fear Street: Prom Queen
WorstWatchers score: 62/100 – higher = worse
Prom dress, fire axe, zero suspense — Shadyside crowns boredom.
Shadyside, May 23, 1988: on prom night, outcast Lori Granger runs for prom queen against the ruthless "Wolfpack" clique led by queen bee Tiffany Falconer. Lori is a pariah at school because her mother was once suspected of murdering her father. The night before, candidate Christy Renault dies by a masked killer's fire axe, and at the dance he thins out the contenders and their dates room by room. Matt Palmer directs and co-wrote the loose adaptation of R. L. Stine's 1992 novel "The Prom Queen" with Donald McLeary; it is the fourth entry in the Netflix series after the 2021 trilogy. It was shot in Toronto and Hamilton in 2024 and premiered on Netflix on May 23, 2025. Critics were far harsher than with the trilogy: Rotten Tomatoes calls it a tired '80s retread of better slashers.
Pros
- Per IndieWire (83/100), it blitzes through its pop-comic vignettes and at least makes its characters' nightmares a little freakier.
- Screen Rant (60/100) says the standalone entry in the same Shadyside universe continues the trilogy's fun.
- A solid cast, with Lili Taylor, Katherine Waterston, and Chris Klein in the adult roles (Wikipedia).
Cons
- Rotten Tomatoes just 28 percent from 71 reviews, audience 24 percent; Metascore 41, Letterboxd 1.68 out of 5.
- Paste Magazine says it steals shamelessly from its influences while showing little original thought.
- Per Wikipedia, critics rated it clearly below the three earlier films.