Fantasy Island
WorstWatchers score: 71/100 – higher = worse
Blumhouse turns the series into horror — the wish for quality goes unanswered.
Fantasy Island (2020) turns the TV dream locale into a death trap. Rotten Tomatoes: 9 percent, Metacritic: 22. Instead of clever high concept, critics saw predictable twists and flat characters. You stay out of series nostalgia.
Pros
- Blumhouse horror promise with a known IP (Wikipedia).
- Tropical-island looks in moments (Wikipedia).
- Michael Peña as a Mr. Roarke variant (Wikipedia).
Cons
- Only 9 percent Tomatometer (Rotten Tomatoes).
- Metacritic 22/100 (Metacritic).
- Critics: predictable, characters thin (Wikipedia).