Elemental: War of Magic

2010 Game Strategy

WorstWatchers score: 50/100 – higher = worse

A fantasy empire built on crash reports.

Stardock wanted with Elemental: War of Magic in August 2010 nothing less than "a strategy game in a role-playing world". In a world devastated by the Titans you lead humans or the corrupted Fallen, build cities, design your own units, and take heroes on quests. Research, resources, magic, and conquest were meant to fuse into one big 4X package. At launch the game crashed so often that PC Gamer, GameSpot, and GamePro only published their reviews after patches. The turn: after the sequel Fallen Enchantress Stardock pulled the game from sale entirely — and then brought it back in 2026 as a remaster.

Pros

  • Megalomania in the best sense: critics per Wikipedia expressly praised ambition and strategic freedom.
  • Build your own units and take heroes on quests — on paper a dream for 4X nerds (Wikipedia).
  • GameSpot found under all the annoyance a "solid game foundation" with "many worthy ideas and ambitions".

Cons

  • Metacritic 53: crashes, weak interface, and broken AI ran per Wikipedia through almost every review.
  • G4 called it "a work in progress"; 1UP simply "just isn't fun".
  • Tom Chick found it "disappointingly primitive" and saw the work missing that it already needed in beta.

Worst-of lists · Explorer