Darkfall

2009 Game Role-playing

WorstWatchers score: 50/100 – higher = worse

A fantasy MMO where you take your pants off before a fight just in case.

Darkfall was an MMORPG by Greek firm Aventurine, originally announced in 2001 by a small Oslo team and after years of delays launched in Europe in February 2009. On the vast continent Agon there was free PvP for all, full looting of defeated foes, sea battles and clan cities, but no classes and no levels. Whoever wanted to get stronger had to grind skills through hours of repetition. The game became known mainly through a dispute: Eurogamer gave 2 of 10; Aventurine claimed server logs showed almost no playtime by the tester. The turn: Eurogamer had Kieron Gillen retest — and the game climbed to a proud 4 of 10.

Pros

  • Ambitious: open world, free PvP, full looting, and fights without classes or levels (Wikipedia).
  • Game Observer per Wikipedia even gave 83 of 100; Meristation 7 of 10.
  • Kieron Gillen compared it to EVE Online, which also began as a niche game with good ideas (Eurogamer via MMORPG.com).

Cons

  • Eurogamer's first review: days of smacking the same goblins, "not enjoying one second of it" (Brokentoys/Eurogamer).
  • Gillen describes players stripping to underwear before fights so they lose nothing: "stupid beyond all mortal belief".
  • Gillen's verdict: rewards too far, the path there too dull to recommend it (Eurogamer via MMORPG.com).

Worst-of lists · Explorer