Cutthroat Island
WorstWatchers score: 54/100 – higher = worse
Geena Davis as a pirate – one of the biggest box-office bombs in film history.
Jamaica, 1668: pirate Morgan Adams (Geena Davis) hunts her uncle Dawg (Frank Langella), who has kidnapped her father. Her father holds one of three pieces of a map to a stash of gold on remote Cutthroat Island and, dying, tells her it is on his scalp. With the rogue William Shaw (Matthew Modine), Morgan sets out to find the remaining pieces before Dawg. Renny Harlin directed the 1995 adventure film; on a $92–98 million budget it grossed only about $16 million worldwide. Guinness World Records listed it as the biggest box-office bomb of all time, and its failure caused Carolco Pictures to cease operations. Per the Rotten Tomatoes consensus it lacks charm and has a stilted script; Metacritic gives it 37 out of 100.
Pros
- A rare female pirate lead.
- Matthew Modine as rogue William Shaw.
- Frank Langella as the villain.
Cons
- Biggest box-office bomb of all time, per Guinness.
- Lacks charm, per the RT consensus.
- Variety: strenuous but vain.