Boxing Helena

1993 Movie Drama, Thriller

WorstWatchers score: 72/100 – higher = worse

A surgeon, an obsession, an amputation – Jennifer Lynch's notorious debut.

Surgeon Nick Cavanaugh (Julian Sands) is obsessed with his neighbour Helena (Sherilyn Fenn), who rejects him after a single night together. When she is injured in a hit-and-run as she leaves his house, he kidnaps her and amputates first her legs, later her arms, to keep her with him. Even so, Helena dominates the dialogue, ridiculing him constantly. Jennifer Lynch wrote and directed the film from a story by Philippe Caland; Madonna and Kim Basinger had both backed out of the lead role, leading to legal battles. After premiering at Sundance in 1993 it was first rated NC-17, reached US cinemas with an R rating on appeal, and flopped. The Rotten Tomatoes consensus calls it more tedious than provocative; Gene Siskel (Chicago Tribune) was among its few defenders.

Pros

  • An uncompromisingly disturbing concept.
  • Nominated for the Grand Jury Prize at Sundance.
  • Gene Siskel defended the film.

Cons

  • More tedious than provocative, per the RT consensus.
  • Graceless execution of a touchy idea.
  • A commercial flop.

Worst-of lists · Explorer