Ashes of Creation
WorstWatchers score: 73/100 – higher = worse
Nine years of hype, two months of play, zero studio.
Ashes of Creation promised the MMORPG the genre had been waiting for: a living fantasy world called Verra where player actions grow camps into villages and villages into cities with politics and housing. In 2017 Intrepid Studios raised over $3.2 million on Kickstarter, cracking the goal in under twelve hours. After years of alpha tests at a $500 preorder price, the game entered Steam Early Access on December 11, 2025. Ambition drew praise; performance, bugs, and cheaters drew complaints. The turn: in late January 2026 founder Steven Sharif resigned "in protest," the studio issued layoffs for the entire staff, and in early February the game vanished from Steam sales.
Pros
- Grandeur with style: players were meant to shape settlements into cities with politics via the node system — GamesRadar+ called it a "living, reactive world" (Wikipedia).
- Hype record: the $750,000 Kickstarter goal fell in under twelve hours; the campaign closed above $3.2 million (Wikipedia, GamesRadar+).
- PCGamesN once called it "a beacon of hope" for the MMO genre — the resignation-and-fraud drama reads more thrilling than any quest (Wikipedia).
Cons
- Steam reviews only 25 percent positive from over 8,400 ratings, just 7 percent in the last 30 days.
- Studio gone: per Wikipedia the WARN notice describes a permanent closure with 123 laid off; PCGamesN reports the Steam sales halt in early February 2026.
- Shaky before that: GamesRadar+ cites a developer letter on performance, bugs, and cheaters; PCGamesN reports Kickstarter backers fretting over refund promises.