16 and Pregnant
WorstWatchers score: 50/100 – higher = worse
Educational TV that suspiciously feels like a casting call.
16 and Pregnant launched June 2009 on MTV and dedicates each episode to a different pregnant high-school girl. The camera usually starts in months five to eight and stays until the baby is a few months old, interrupted by doodle animations on school notebook paper. Shown are doctor visits, births, fights with the father and parents, sometimes also the choice of adoption. MTV sold it as a warning; critics saw more melodrama with a baby bump. The turn: a 2014 study credited the show with a share of the teen-birth decline; a later study dismantled that finding again.
Pros
- Per Wikipedia a teen-pregnancy campaign counted the show in 2009 among reasons for falling numbers.
- Common Sense Media sees potential for "constructive conversations" between parents and teens.
- A Metacritic critic calls it a "compelling docuseries" — and the Teen Mom spin-off tree is huge.
Cons
- A Metacritic critic: what MTV bills as a warning is "train-wreck TV at its saddest".
- Common Sense Media: more "voyeuristically melodramatic than informative"; the actual pregnancy becomes secondary.
- Per Wikipedia criticized for lack of diversity and the charge of glamorizing teen pregnancy.